I recently read a post over on API Speaks, where the author was sharing her thoughts (and worries) about potential child spacing. Man, have I thought about this issue a LOT. It is a much-discussed topic among parents of young children -- there are so many of us wondering if, when (and sometimes how) to grow our families, and what, in an ideal world, would work best for our own particular circumstances. (I will admit here that as an ex-infertile I know how frustrating the whole "timing" discussions can be for some people -- when folks just assume they will get pregnant on the drop of a hat when they decide. I feel much less annoyed by it all now, having put some distance -- and three kids -- between those challenging times for us.)
In attachment parenting circles, it seems a lot of folks worry about spacing too closely, wanting to allow each child as much attention and connection as possible in the early years. Some practical issues definitely color this decision for some, in terms of bedsharing/cosleeping, breastfeeding beyond infancy, and babywearing. Many of us agree that those are all great physical parenting tools for toddlers and preschoolers, not just infants, but if a new baby comes along, sometimes its just not possible to manage that kind of contact with two (or more, ha) kids. Having two or more kids under 2, 3 or even 4 or 5 can be really draining, tapping a parent's emotional and physical resources beyond what feels comfortable. Maintaining a solid attachment to two or more babies or toddlers, and finding ways to "fill up their cups" (giving one-one attention) is HARD. Gentle, positive discipline takes time, energy, and patience that is sometimes lacking when there are many small people and lots of big needs.
Lonnie and I always knew we wanted at least two kids. I think we both kind of hoped to space them closely, while we were still young and energetic (ha) and not very entrenched in our grown-up routines and kid-free lifestyle (maybe this is projecting, though I see it as a benefit, after the fact). Career-wise, I was in a place where I was not sure where I wanted to go, and staying home with kids was an easy sell. Starting a new career after one baby, then taking a break in a year or two for number two and/or three just didn't make sense. Close spacing seemed right for us.
Since we had fertility issues before conceiving Emma, we wanted to start trying again soonish, expecting it to take years, possibly. I started gently spacing Emma's frequent nursing during the day at 15 months, and had my first period within two weeks. And then, shockingly, conceived twins that next cycle. OMG! We were both overjoyed that it had not been difficult to conceive this time around, and freaked out (at least I was) that it had happened SO soon. That was not exactly how I had envisioned it.
I then got pretty sick and tired that first tri, and felt SO AWFUL about it all — Emma was still so young, so needy, sensitive and clingy, and I felt like I was unable to mother her the way I wanted. I fretted about my connection to her, her having to grow up too soon, all the changes we were going to have to make, yada yada yada. Some of that was valid, but some was just the emotional issues from being pregnant and tired, for sure. It was SO rough, especially as we adjusted to the news, but it was also just a blip, in the longer term.
We did have to start making changes, though. First nightweaning Emma (which we actually started before I knew I was pregnant), then moving her to her own bed and room (while still cosleeping with her for quite awhile– gradually less as she grew used to it). Lonnie took on more and more of her care, especially at bedtime, though I was still home with her all day. I weaned her completely around 20 months (a little more than halfway through my pregnancy) — I knew I could not nurse 3 after they were born! We also started her in daycare a few mornings a week, to give me a break (we were also moving, so I had to pack!). That was HARD, and she reacted strongly to being separated at first, but we kept trying and she eventually got used to it and started having fun.
I probably would have held off on many of those changes for a bit longer -- or not done it at all -- if I had not been pregnant. I think she was for the most part ready for them, though was pushed a bit more than I'd prefer. But each step, taken over the span of 9 months or so, really did help us all prepare for the babies' arrival. Making changes slowly, gradually over the course of weeks and months, allowed Emma (and me!) to adjust pretty well. She stepped up to the new challenges and surprised me, adapting pretty quickly to the new ways of doing things.
Emma was two when Elsie and Delia were born. 3 under 3 is definitely hard, and crazy, and exhausting! We were lucky that Emma loved babies (real and pretend) and enjoyed helping out, and also was pretty good at playing independently. She didn't seem to need the level of physical activity that I know some toddlers need, too -- thank goodness -- since we didn't get out very much! At the time we were just in survival mode for a good 7-8 months, but I was pretty much expecting that since we were having twins, so it felt okay. There were many times, though, where I struggled with what I felt was best for babies (in terms of sleep, physical contact, and responding to cries) and what I was able to do with twins and a toddler. I hated having to do some things differently than I had with Emma (including letting Elsie and Delia cry it out for naptime), but then again, the girls all seemed to adapt and go with the flow pretty well, and never seemed worse for wear.
Many people talk about the "village" or "tribe" concept, in terms of having a community that supports mothers during the early days, months, and years. I think this is HUGE. Our culture is just not designed to support new mothers with young children. Our extended families are far apart, we are so removed from our neighbors, and our communities (workplaces included) often don't have good, welcoming spaces or policies that include and support young children and the mothers who care for them. Taking care of the needs of several (or more) babies or toddlers by yourself is crazy making, and sometimes physically impossible.
Despite all the modern appliances and baby gear stacked around our house, and a wealth of information about baby care and twins easily searched for online or in books, what I really needed in the early days (and arguably still now!) was more sets of loving arms, more friends, relatives and peers working side by side with me, sharing chores, swapping stories and advice. I am still so thankful that we did have one grandparent or another living with us for the first 2.5 months after Elsie and Delia were born -- whew! I literally could not have done it (breastfeeding, anyway) without that. I do feel like now, at home alone during the day with 3 kids under 5, I am not the best parent I could be, in terms of staying calm, gentle and positive, because I am overwhelmed with need and toddler antics.
So in retrospect, in an ideal world, wider spacing would probably have been better for us at least during these early months and years, especially withtwins! There are things I certainly wished I could have done differently -- both for Emma as a toddler, Elsie and Delia as infants, and even all three, now. On the flip side, the spacing worked great for us in terms of my staying home with them, condensing this period of caring for young children into a few short years. And at age two, Emma adjusted to the “new normal” of having two babies in the house super, super fast — she soon could not remember life without her sisters, so we had very little jealousy issues. Now at age two and four, they all play really well together, and I see that only getting better and better...
There are pros and cons to all different spacings, and I know folks who swear by each of them. And no matter what you "plan", this kind of thing doesn't always go according to your schedule, anyway! No matter what happens, you make it work the best you can. Some phases are challenging, but kids grow and change so fast, no one stage will last forever. This is what keeps me going, when the going gets rough!
What are/were your thoughts or plans for child spacing? Did it pan out for you, or do you wish it had gone a bit differently? What have you learned along the way?